Biblical Criticism & History Forum - earlywritings.com

You're simply not capable of even pretending to see any other point of view than what you have decided is the truth. So in this case, the argument that there was a book of Clement of Alexandria in the Mar Saba library only works if you assume a priori that Morton Smith is the forger. What you can't ...

Please pretend that you are capable of seeing that there would be no volume of Clement of Alexandria available for an eighteenth century scribe to use. A thumbs up sign perhaps if you are incapable of typing words to this effect?

Deflection. Please you can never accuse anyone at this forum of this "sin." You are the king of deflection at Early Writings since you have only two settings with regards to posting at the forum on the letter. On topic and off topic accusations that Morton Smith did it. Your off topic comm...

My message to Russell Gmirkin. Dear Dr. Gmirkin You misquote me dishonestly in the Early Writings forum. You say I wrote that the Samaritan Joshua is "secondary and very late". This is dishonest misquotation by omission. I said that the MT and THE PRESENT FORM of the Samaritan Joshua are s...

Oh I forgot. Goranson is only a first generation Mar Saba letter commenting bot. He only has two settings. Setting One: making on topic assumptions that the letter is a fake. Setting Two: making off topic assumptions that the letter is fake. Only the next generation Stephen Goranson Mar Saba comment...

If this isn't deflection what is? Did you address his point at all? Sadly this is not at all surprising. Admit he's right. Thanks.

Go home, you are drunk man The analogy is perfect. Ridiculous claims. Implausible plot. Idiotic character development. But everyone goes along with it. https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj-b4iPD9ToZ58Xzwnf8AKoYMvULRsRa5_jqkdXfQaK3KkjpxwfC23fdO7j8jBOdIUK4KKmU1w_INU_GosdnmAoeE...

The proper analogy is porn. The idea that the proper number of gospels in the world is four and every heresy corresponds to one gospel and Irenaeus knows that the one gospel of the four that is Marcion's gospel is Luke is like. https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgevcCgsWwre06...

Marcion.

1 Paul, a servant of Christ Jesus, called to be an apostle, set apart for the gospel of God, (Rom 1.1) Origen’s Interpretation: (5) ‘Set apart,’ he says. ‘for the gospel of God.’ Other passages of Scripture speak of the gospel of Christ, as the evangelist Mark writes, ‘The beginning of the gospel o...