Divine Placebo Research Proposal: A Help Request

What do they believe? What do you think? Talk about religion as it exists today.

Moderator: JoeWallack

Post Reply
User avatar
neilgodfrey
Posts: 6161
Joined: Sat Oct 05, 2013 4:08 pm

Divine Placebo Research Proposal: A Help Request

Post by neilgodfrey »

Dr Patrik Lindenfors, an associate professor at the Stockholm University, has asked me if I would be willing to help him by advertising his crowdfunded research.

See the Website for the project, Divine Placebo

His proposal is to review potential placebo effects of religion and how these may explain why religious beliefs and practices are so common across human populations.

Because this is not his normal area of research he is asking for public assistance. Looks to me like he's running out of time so don't delay if you wish to donate.

From his website:
In my regular work I am a researcher of cultural evolution at Stockholm University. I have previously authored the books God Probably Doesn’t Exist, which has been translated into seven languages, and “Samarbete“, a popular science book in Swedish about the biological and cultural evolution of cooperation, currently being translated into English.

Now, I want to explore a proposal that has circulated in books and on-line discussions for a while – if there are any placebo effects of religion and whether these may be a partial explanation of the spread of religious beliefs and practices across human societies. The funding I ask for will utilized as salary during the book writing process.

Scientific studies have found measurable effects of sham treatments on several different ailments – placebo effects. Religious rituals often invoke very similar mechanisms as those used to invoke such placebo responses, including suggestion, trust in authority figures, generated expectations and classical Pavlovian conditioning. In this way placebo (beneficial) and nocebo (detrimental) effects may function as religion’s stick and carrot, something which may have expedited the spread and maintenance of religious beliefs and rituals across human populations.

Importantly, placebos can provide actual benefits, resulting in both immediate and evolutionary advantages for people who are persuaded by pretend treatments and religious practices. This indicates real benefits of gullibility and suggestibility in humans, providing an explanation of the universal spread of religions across human populations. In the final chapter of the book I will discuss potential methods to harness the power of placebo for the benefit of the ever growing number of people who are not religious.

The field of evolutionary research on religion is exploding, with new research groups, journals and papers emerging all the time. Thus, there should be a ripe market for a book reviewing and summarizing a novel general argument.

I plan to write the book in English, in an easily accessible manner and with an anti-theistic slant, tapping into the large audience reading atheistic literature.
His academic website - http://www.zoologi.su.se/research/lindenfors/

Facebook page with more details - https://www.facebook.com/divineplacebo
vridar.org Musings on biblical studies, politics, religion, ethics, human nature, tidbits from science
Mental flatliner
Posts: 486
Joined: Wed May 07, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Divine Placebo Research Proposal: A Help Request

Post by Mental flatliner »

neilgodfrey wrote:Dr Patrik Lindenfors, an associate professor at the Stockholm University, has asked me if I would be willing to help him by advertising his crowdfunded research.

See the Website for the project, Divine Placebo

His proposal is to review potential placebo effects of religion and how these may explain why religious beliefs and practices are so common across human populations.

Because this is not his normal area of research he is asking for public assistance. Looks to me like he's running out of time so don't delay if you wish to donate.

From his website:
In my regular work I am a researcher of cultural evolution at Stockholm University. I have previously authored the books God Probably Doesn’t Exist, which has been translated into seven languages, and “Samarbete“, a popular science book in Swedish about the biological and cultural evolution of cooperation, currently being translated into English.

Now, I want to explore a proposal that has circulated in books and on-line discussions for a while – if there are any placebo effects of religion and whether these may be a partial explanation of the spread of religious beliefs and practices across human societies. The funding I ask for will utilized as salary during the book writing process.

Scientific studies have found measurable effects of sham treatments on several different ailments – placebo effects. Religious rituals often invoke very similar mechanisms as those used to invoke such placebo responses, including suggestion, trust in authority figures, generated expectations and classical Pavlovian conditioning. In this way placebo (beneficial) and nocebo (detrimental) effects may function as religion’s stick and carrot, something which may have expedited the spread and maintenance of religious beliefs and rituals across human populations.

Importantly, placebos can provide actual benefits, resulting in both immediate and evolutionary advantages for people who are persuaded by pretend treatments and religious practices. This indicates real benefits of gullibility and suggestibility in humans, providing an explanation of the universal spread of religions across human populations. In the final chapter of the book I will discuss potential methods to harness the power of placebo for the benefit of the ever growing number of people who are not religious.

The field of evolutionary research on religion is exploding, with new research groups, journals and papers emerging all the time. Thus, there should be a ripe market for a book reviewing and summarizing a novel general argument.

I plan to write the book in English, in an easily accessible manner and with an anti-theistic slant, tapping into the large audience reading atheistic literature.
His academic website - http://www.zoologi.su.se/research/lindenfors/

Facebook page with more details - https://www.facebook.com/divineplacebo
Okay. Correct me if I'm wrong:

Such an experiment seems to require two subjects (or two groups), and I'll use Christians as if they were the intended target group:
1--Christians who rely on a deity that exists
2--People who can be given a placebo of some kind that mimics a deity that exists

Where do they intend to get participants for the first group, and how exactly will they be screened for appropriateness?

(In other words, how can you rationally test a placebo of something if you can't test the real thing and compare results?)
Post Reply