Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
This is pure speculation on my part. I'm curious if anyone has ever attempted any serious scholarly work on determining whether Tacitus used Josephus' writings as a source, and if so, whether Tacitus' description of Jesus (as the instigator of a superstition who was crucified under Pilate) may have been sourced from a pre-tampered with Testimonium Flavianum?
My study list: https://www.facebook.com/notes/scott-bignell/judeo-christian-origins-bibliography/851830651507208
- Tenorikuma
- Posts: 374
- Joined: Thu Nov 14, 2013 6:40 am
Re: Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
If you mean the original Tacitus used a tampered-with copy of Josephus, the timeline doesn't work. It was probably Pamphilus (as Carrier believes) or Eusebius who created the TF.
Re: Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
^I'm talking about the possibility of Tacitus getting his info on Jesus from a pre-tampered-with Josephus reference to Jesus, and whether anyone's ever explored that idea to any scholarly length.
My study list: https://www.facebook.com/notes/scott-bignell/judeo-christian-origins-bibliography/851830651507208
Re: Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
Its unlikely a "pre-tampered-with" TF would have reference to Jesus the Christ, Christ per se, or to Christians.
- Ben C. Smith
- Posts: 8994
- Joined: Wed Apr 08, 2015 2:18 pm
- Location: USA
- Contact:
Re: Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
S. C. Carlson makes such a case on two old weblog entries: http://hypotyposeis.org/weblog/2004/08/ ... ebius.html and http://hypotyposeis.org/weblog/2004/08/ ... onium.html. He has follow-up posts that he collects here: http://hypotyposeis.org/weblog/2006/07/ ... eries.html. (At that time I was fairly enthusiastic about the case; I am not as sure now; Ken Olson makes some good points.)toejam wrote:This is pure speculation on my part. I'm curious if anyone has ever attempted any serious scholarly work on determining whether Tacitus used Josephus' writings as a source, and if so, whether Tacitus' description of Jesus (as the instigator of a superstition who was crucified under Pilate) may have been sourced from a pre-tampered with Testimonium Flavianum?
Ben.
ΤΙ ΕΣΤΙΝ ΑΛΗΘΕΙΑ
Re: Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
^Yeah, I'm not enthusiastic about it either... just seeing if anyone's explored the possibility before...
My study list: https://www.facebook.com/notes/scott-bignell/judeo-christian-origins-bibliography/851830651507208
Re: Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
Tacitus, Pliny-the-Younger, Seutonius and Hadrian were all contemporaries of each other
Re: Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
Pliny-the-Younger was friends with both Tacitus and Seutonius, and Suetonius became employed by Hadrian.
They collectively referred to Christ, Christians, Chrestus, and Chrestiani; but not Jesus.
They collectively referred to Christ, Christians, Chrestus, and Chrestiani; but not Jesus.
Last edited by MrMacSon on Thu Dec 28, 2017 9:29 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
^I've engaged with you on this point before, and I found it an unfruitful conversation. If you don't think the reference found in Tacitus' Annals 15:44, which describes a Judean cult leader who was executed under Pilate as the instigator of a sizable superstition, is a reference to Jesus because it doesn't say "Jesus", then I think you're fooling yourself. That would be like saying the phrase "in the 1950s, there was a tall pasty red-head who started $cientology" isn't a reference to L. Ron Hubbard. If you can't see this and would like to engage on this point, start a new thread. In this thread, we're working on the assumptions that Tacitus' passage is authentic, and that Josephus wrote *something* about Jesus in a pre-tampered with TF, and whether or not anyone has ever explored in any detail the thought that this may have been Tacitus' source for his passage.
My study list: https://www.facebook.com/notes/scott-bignell/judeo-christian-origins-bibliography/851830651507208
- Peter Kirby
- Site Admin
- Posts: 8617
- Joined: Fri Oct 04, 2013 2:13 pm
- Location: Santa Clara
- Contact:
Re: Josephus' TF the source for Tacitus' reference to Jesus?
Well perhaps we can bring it back into context.
In the Josephus passage, so-called, then there is -no- statement about Jesus being Christ... unless one thinks that the passage was unedited. The distinction is made that Jesus is "called the Christ" (20.200 and 18.63 both allegedly have such wording). But the person is introduced as "Jesus."
On the other hand, the Latin-writing Tacitus seems to share the perspective of Pliny and Suetonius, by referring to this person as "Christ."
If Tacitus read Josephus, he was none the wiser for doing so, in that he does not call Jesus by his actual name.
In the Josephus passage, so-called, then there is -no- statement about Jesus being Christ... unless one thinks that the passage was unedited. The distinction is made that Jesus is "called the Christ" (20.200 and 18.63 both allegedly have such wording). But the person is introduced as "Jesus."
On the other hand, the Latin-writing Tacitus seems to share the perspective of Pliny and Suetonius, by referring to this person as "Christ."
If Tacitus read Josephus, he was none the wiser for doing so, in that he does not call Jesus by his actual name.
"... almost every critical biblical position was earlier advanced by skeptics." - Raymond Brown