It would be interesting to cross-reference those writers/texts with "believed in a historical Jesus". If they believed in a HJ but not referencing the Gospels, then does this suggest another source of data? Papias certainly suggests that oral transmission was important up until his time.Kapyong wrote:Where :
Green = knows and approves of Gospel(s),
Red = knows and dis-approves of the Gospel(s).
I'd also be interested in any writer who actually disapproves of the Gospels. By "disapprove", do you mean "not treat as authoritative"?
I've expanded your list with others up to 155 CE. Many of the dates I've taken from either my review of Doherty's J:NGNM or the Early Christian Writings website. I've changed the underlining to reflect "Refers to written 'Gospel(s)'", since the use of 'gospel' doesn't necessarily refer to written sources.
Text | HJ Statements? | Date |
Didache | Yes | 50-120 |
Barnabas | Yes | 95-125 |
1 Clement | ? | 96 |
Cerinthus | Yes | 100? |
2 Peter | Yes | 100-160 |
1 Timothy | Yes | 100-150 |
Ignatius | Yes | 105-115 (Shorter) |
Papias | Yes | 110-130 |
Polycarp | Yes | 110-140 |
Basilides | Yes | 120-140 |
Quadratus | Yes | 120-130 |
Aristides | Yes | 140 |
Acts of Apostles | Yes | 80-130 |
2 Clement | ? | 130-160 |
Justin | Yes | 150s |
Minucius Felix | ? | 160? |
Green = Refers to written 'Gospel(s)'
Notes:
1. Some of the texts refer to 'gospels' but not as apparently written sources (e.g. Didache, Barnabas). I didn't underline them above.
2. Some of the texts appear to quote from our extant Gospels, but they don't cite Gospels as their source (e.g. Ignatius). I didn't underline them above. See also Richard Carrier's "Formation of the NT Canon" for reference.
3. Some of the authors were gnostics, but I have marked them as 'Yes' in the HJ column if they believed that their Jesus Christ interacted with people on earth.
4. I put a question mark for M. Felix, but I would put a 'Yes' in that column personally! 1 and 2 Clement also appear to make HJ statements (e.g. 1 Clement appears to refer to Jesus Christ being a descendent of Judah), but they are ambiguous.