Biblical Criticism & History Forum - earlywritings.com

IMO, you, JarekS, have not shown that "The corpus was created and edited in one place."

In the latest Revue de Qumran, t. 35, f. 2 no. 122, pages 161-173 (I do consider RevQ a good source, even if no academic source is infallible. Full disclosure: I have published in RevQ.) Andrew Perrot and Emile Puech, "Cryptic C 4Q363a as a Palaeo-Hebrew Manuscript: 4Qpalaeo-Hebrew 363a" A...

Thanks for your comment, Andrew. Of course leitourgia *is* relevant if Morton Smith composed it, with his misunderstanding of that. I now have a copy of The Secret Gospel: The Discovery etc. at hand. By the way, MS mentioned leitourgia on page 7 But on another matter Andrew, if I may, having reread ...

Actually, the singular makes more sense than the plural, in the context.

If the handwriting were *actually* from the 18th century, not just similar-looking --though AT says it was later, and I think so too-- then Smith would not be the writer (composer and maybe penner). Btw, even if it *were* from 18th c. that would not necessarily prove it was penned at Mar Saba, espec...

Russell Gmirkin's claim that the first five books of the Hebrew Bible were "composed in their entirely about 273-272 BCE" in Alexandria is also, in my view, quite false. (The quote is from his 2006 Berossus and Genesis book.) As far as I know, though, Gmirkin is not a Dr. nor has he claime...

I wrote about the "Letter to Theodore."
SA accused me of writing about it too much and too little, both. Hm.
A deflection here might be, say, to write about soccer.

A.T., writing on 1715, was ambiguous. Apparently he thought it relevant.

SA wrote, Mon Apr 22, 2024 7:02 am, in part: "I would be very surprised if you could even one example of a text of one author being written into the blank pages of a book written by the same author. [etc. etc.]" I have some books. Most of my books I do not write in. But three of them come ...

a) The Letter was in a hand, made later, imitating an earlier script, according to A. T. Correct, imo. b) A.T.'s report, included, to repeat: "12. Interesting is the case of the existence of old printed books in the Library of St. Sabba. According the catalogue of 263 old printed books that pat...

"...unwillingness to bring up Secret Mark was shared by Origen."

What, beyond silence, if anything expressible, possessed you to claim that about Origen?