Biblical Criticism & History Forum - earlywritings.com

Klinghardt says that Mark made Romans the torturers, who in *Ev were the guards of the Sanhedrin. In this way the gentiles are guilty and not only the Jews That's how it is in John, the Romans torture unlike the synoptic account But this is masked by the repeated rejection scene's and general anti-...

I agree. Klinghardt frequently frames questions about readings as false dichotomies, positing them as a strict choice between them being Marcion's own redaction of Luke or in the Evangelion before Marcion and therefore pre-Lukan and the original reading of the gospels, as though those choices exhau...

I agree. Klinghardt frequently frames questions about readings as false dichotomies, positing them as a strict choice between them being Marcion's own redaction of Luke or in the Evangelion before Marcion and therefore pre-Lukan and the original reading of the gospels, as though those choices exhau...

Mark misunderstanding the word "pancakes" for "locusts" (which was then picked up by Matthew and Luke). I suppose the argument is reversible, if someone thinks it plausible that Mark depends on the Greek gEbionites. On the other hand, it seems impossible to misunderstand the lon...

LSJ 1940 ἐκλέγω fut. Pass. ἐκλεγήσεσθαι IG1². 76.16 ; pf. Pass. ἐξείλεγμαι Pl. Alc. 1.121e, and in med. sense, D. 20.131, but ἐκλέλεγμαι Diph. 44, Posidipp. 27.9 (prob.) : — pick or single out, Th. 4.59, etc. ; esp. of soldiers, rowers, etc., X. HG 1.6.19, Pl. R. 535a ; ἐκ πάντων κεφάλαια Id. Lg. 8...

Ok but first of all, the second bit of highlighted text was NOT WRITTEN BY ME. I’ll get back to you about the rest. Check, you are right. I can only blame my own fat fingers lol your question clearly and unequivocally is What is the basis for asserting that Marcion was an “enemy of Judaism and the ...

And the XLSX source to my paper on the 72 logia, with a few handy calculations

viewtopic.php?p=123555#p123555

I don't have a link to his whole model at the moment, but his discussion of the Bethsaida section and its implications for gMark is here: https://earlywritings.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=2554 It's more fun to include highlighted text with it: https://earlywritings.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=2...

I've added two Thomas - where did you get the parallels that you had? Thanks! I added them. I've been using The Five Gospel Parallels online. I'll supplement with The Complete Gospel Parallels (which would pick up Thomas 104 at least). Thank you Peter. A handy one pager of *Ev-Thomas is https://ear...

Do yourself and everyone else a favour, and stop posting for a while. Or rather, you can write them but not Submit them, alright? Just put them in draft, let them simmer for a day, then read them again. And ask yourself what impressions they give to the outside world. I for one see the evolution of ...