Biblical Criticism & History Forum - earlywritings.com

This fixation with Josephus is stupid and betrays a small intellect. I guess I'll have to remove all of the Tacitus, Suetonius and Dio stuff from my work in order to make it conform to your narrow consideration of material you haven't read and know nothing about. Bye, Hasmoneans. Bye-bye Plutarch. ...

1. First, the higher level Form Criticism: But this doesn't help us understand the story at all. Does to. Does not. To, to, to. Not, not, not. I WIN!!! 2. It doesn't stand on its own as an argument. Instead it is little more than an ornament on the silly practice that Joe Atwill initiated of 'matchi...

Do you really believe that this is any way connected with what Mark is writing about? That's madness. Wars..., 5, 3, 4: " "Truly," says Titus, "the laws of war cannot but groan heavily, as will my father also himself, when he shall be informed of this wound that hath been given ...

The sentence about the trees in Mark makes no sense in Greek. Black as I remember appeals to Aramaic. But Greek does not seem to be the original language. If you fiddle around with substitutions you can make it say "I see people that I see walking like trees" but this is silly. Something ...

Peter Kirby wrote:I'm not sure there is a smoking gun against the Farrer hypothesis, but I'm not sure there's one against Q either.

Goin' fishin' again, PK?

I think we should all admit (not that it will ever happen) that the basis to developing a viable hypothesis is establishing something that can be proved or at least demonstrated independently of the presuppositions we hold dear. In other words, we shouldn't need to believe in something in order to ...

The Hasmonean elements came via Josephus. What you see by the time of the Flavians is already a composite character, but it doesn't mean he was always a composite. This is not true. The Hasmoneans existed , seen today by way of coins, other records in other cultures, etc. "Existence" is n...

Carotta gives dozens or even hundreds of examples of coincidences. But it's also the emplotment, and how the Divus Iulius cult came before Christianity. Also, the Divus Iulius cult predates even Antigonus's execution. ghost: You are at the doorstep of Joe Atwill here and I believe that Atwill is th...

And Charles, how is it possible that all that you say, all that maryhelena says, all that ghost says could all be true at the same time? It's madness. 1. All nonsense aside, SH, I have enjoyed your work - as you should know from your site. I believe that we are on opposite sides of a dividing line....

Yeah, like that Kook that wrote that book on young Marcus Agrippa. He was so sure that he had cracked the thing wide open.
Then, he started calling it his "...silly, little book...".

Yeah. Like that guy.