Biblical Criticism & History Forum - earlywritings.com

"Alas, the thread dealing with such a thing was deleted from reddit and from its archives, which you will probably interpret as evidence that I am lying about such a claim. But here are the links if you are interested: https://vridar.org/2020/11/16/bad-histo ... issenters/, in which I cite http...

"Imagine confusing the number of scholars you can dig up with the quality of the evidence." But am I *really* making this confusion? I actually commented at longer length on the quality of the evidence earlier in this very thread, on page 3 I think. The quality is that, well, there's no qu...

"I am only raising the possibility that such a taboo may be arising." And you do so based on just as much evidence that you or Neil has that any of these passages are interpolations to begin with based on one or two scholars you dug up from the 1960s, LOL. Imagine if mythicists were fine w...

"That one is news to me. I didn't know I denied the twelve are the twelve disciples." See your response to Gathercole dude, you denied his point that "the twelve" in 1 Cor. 15:4 are "the twelve disciples" as if there's a serious or plausible alternative, LOL. "&quo...

That is a MASSIVE number of comments ABuddhist LOL. 1) Relax dude, it was a pretty obvious joke and you're triggered now because I funnily called myself "Dick (The Jesus Buster Duster) Carrier" LOL. 2) I'm not trying to condemn you dude, just don't use the word "historicist" for ...

That's one whole large list of points that doesn't advance anything. But yes, 1) It was a pretty obvious and hilarious joke 2) Hansen can call himself a "historicist" if he wants, just don't force anyone else into this silliness. There's no such thing as a "Muhammad historicist" ...

"What you say is defamatory. I will report you for this to both Mr Carrier and to this website's administrator." LOL how is what I just said defamatory? I made a joke about being Carrier just fooling you guys this whole time ROFL. But yeah, go tell your daddy Carrier about this. Also, no n...

"I actually can't think of any point off-hand where Carrier and I agree." LOL, I hope you don't actually expect me to believe that. Godfrey, you've incessantly responded to every single person who has ever criticized Carrier in a scholarly medium (and there's a lot of them, as we now both ...

Nah there's no such thing as "historicism" Gisueppe, there's only mythicists and people who don't think Paul is talking about a cosmic storage of sperm in Romans 1:3 based on nothing but extreme wishful thinking. Oh, and was also buried in space per 1 Cor. 15:4, LOL. Not to mention Richard...

Read your response? You mean you're NOT going to copy and paste it for me? Gee! But yes, I've already read what you wrote and I represented you perfectly correctly. "What happens is that nothing happens to them. They are ignored. Their arguments are not addressed seriously. Though sometimes the...