'The Corinthian Correspondence: Redaction, Rhetoric, and History,' by Frank W. Hughes and Robert Jewett

[neilgodfrey]

Has anyone attempted to present a case that the patch-work character of the epistles is arguably the result of persons artificially creating the letters from various other writings identifiable in writings of Justin and others, along with a dash of scribal creativity?

[lclapshaw]

Has anyone attempted to present a case that the patch-work character of the epistles is arguably the result of persons artificially creating the letters from various other writings identifiable in writings of Justin and others, along with a dash of scribal creativity?

No. Not that I know of. But, that is my take on it.

[neilgodfrey]

Has anyone attempted to present a case that the patch-work character of the epistles is arguably the result of persons artificially creating the letters from various other writings identifiable in writings of Justin and others, along with a dash of scribal creativity?

No. Not that I know of. But, that is my take on it.

Have you raised your view with others? What have been their responses?

[lclapshaw]

Has anyone attempted to present a case that the patch-work character of the epistles is arguably the result of persons artificially creating the letters from various other writings identifiable in writings of Justin and others, along with a dash of scribal creativity?

No. Not that I know of. But, that is my take on it.

Have you raised your view with others? What have been their responses?

Working on it right now viewtopic.php?f=3&t=10382

[neilgodfrey]

Has anyone attempted to present a case that the patch-work character of the epistles is arguably the result of persons artificially creating the letters from various other writings identifiable in writings of Justin and others, along with a dash of scribal creativity?

No. Not that I know of. But, that is my take on it.

Have you raised your view with others? What have been their responses?

Working on it right now viewtopic.php?f=3&t=10382

Ouch. Oh. I am not ready to contribute to that, I regret. I want first to pore through Justin (for starters) to see what he wrote that overlaps with Paul and then see where that takes us. Do you know if anyone has done that already? Surely someone must have produced a list of Justin's work annotated with Paul's letter references.

[lclapshaw]

Has anyone attempted to present a case that the patch-work character of the epistles is arguably the result of persons artificially creating the letters from various other writings identifiable in writings of Justin and others, along with a dash of scribal creativity?

No. Not that I know of. But, that is my take on it.

Have you raised your view with others? What have been their responses?

Working on it right now viewtopic.php?f=3&t=10382

Ouch. Oh. I am not ready to contribute to that, I regret. I want first to pore through Justin (for starters) to see what he wrote that overlaps with Paul and then see where that takes us. Do you know if anyone has done that already? Surely someone must have produced a list of Justin's work annotated with Paul's letter references.

Quite alright, I'll be posting my results in a week. Check for urpaul Kata lclapshaw on the 27th. Good luck with your search.

[lclapshaw]

Neil, I found this old thread. viewtopic.php?t=494
Also, Google Paul in the writings of Justin Martyr.

[neilgodfrey]

Neil, I found this old thread. viewtopic.php?t=494
Also, Google Paul in the writings of Justin Martyr.

Thank you. That gives me a nice little cache to start with.

[lclapshaw]

Any time, get ready to read something you posted almost ten years ago tho.