"...too mechanical and even impossible" (Bruno Bauer)
Posted: Thu Apr 20, 2023 1:16 am
While Detering has been able to prove that the first visit of Paul in Jerusalem is probably an interpolation designed to mitigate the Paul's claim to independence in the incipit, now I see that Bruno Bauer is equally able to prove that the second visit is fabricated, too:
(my bold)
The second visit (Galatians 2) assumes really, as premise and conclusion of the meeting, that Jews and gentiles live on two different planets.
The idea that the Gentiles were assigned to Paul and the Jews to the Pillar Apostles is too mechanical and even impossible, since it would have been impossible for Paul to only address the Gentiles and leave the Jews aside. The author loses himself in an equally mechanical separation, like the composer of the Acts of the Apostles, only that he separates the Gentile apostle from contact with the Jews, while the latter only sends him to the Gentiles when his gospel has been offered to the Jews in vain. The mechanism of the author of the Galatians shatters against the historical fact that the Jews and their proselytes in Asia Minor, Greece, and Rome were an essential element of the community from the beginning. This original mixture of the Jewish and Gentile elements – (only later, when the views of the New Testament documents about the genesis of Christianity have undergone complete criticism, can we come to the representation of the fermentation that arose from the penetration of those two elements and had as a consequence the formation of the Christian view) – this chemical process that put both elements in tension and produced a new form of historical consciousness from their fusion, at the same time, refutes the mechanism of the Acts of the Apostles.
(my bold)
The second visit (Galatians 2) assumes really, as premise and conclusion of the meeting, that Jews and gentiles live on two different planets.